Flo Milli has scored an important legal victory in a copyright dispute involving her hit song ‘Never Lose Me’. A US federal judge has dismissed the lawsuit over the instrumental used in the track.
The case began when Baltimore-based artist Shamar Deal claimed ownership of a beat called ‘Youu’. He said he bought an exclusive licence through the online platform Traktrain in 2019. Deal reportedly paid $200 for a 10-year agreement with producer Gerreaux Katana.
However, the same instrumental later appeared in ‘Ron Artest’, a 2023 collaboration between Babyface Ray and 42 Dugg. Flo Milli then sampled that recording for ‘Never Lose Me’.
The song became one of her biggest releases. It reached No. 15 on the Billboard Hot 100 and attracted millions of listeners.
Why Did the Court Dismiss the Case?
The main question was whether Deal legally owned the instrumental after purchasing its exclusive licence.
US District Judge André Birotte Jr. found that Deal had not shown the required copyright ownership. Under US copyright law, an exclusive licence that transfers copyright ownership must meet specific legal requirements.
The judge also noted that the agreement lacked the producer’s required signature. This meant Deal could not establish the legal basis for his infringement claims.
As a result, the court dismissed the lawsuit without allowing Deal to amend his complaint.
What Does This Mean for Music Producers?
The decision highlights the risks of buying and selling beats online.
Platforms such as Traktrain allow producers to sell instrumentals to artists around the world. However, different licences offer different rights. Some allow commercial use, while others provide exclusive rights under specific conditions.
Artists must understand these differences before releasing music. They should also check every agreement and confirm who owns the original recording.
Producers face similar responsibilities. Clear contracts can help prevent disputes when several artists want to use the same instrumental.
Could the Legal Dispute Continue?
Deal’s legal team has indicated plans to appeal the decision. His attorney, Larry Zerner, believes the court reached the wrong conclusion.
Meanwhile, the ruling gives Flo Milli and the other defendants an important legal win.
The case also highlights a growing issue in the music industry. Digital platforms make it easier to buy and sell music, but copyright agreements still require careful attention.
For now, Flo Milli can celebrate a positive outcome in a dispute involving one of her most recognisable songs.